The English Kitchen - Trifle

Helen Saberi and Alan Davidson

136 pages; 187 x 135mm; illustrations?

ISBN 1903018 099 Paperback £8.99

The English Kitchen is a series published by Prospect Books to explore and explain the course of English cookery over the last 300 years. Some of the series delves into historic cookery books to find the origins of particular dishes, other titles concentrate on modern favourites and the ways in which they have been interpreted today and in the recent past.

Trifle is the first in the series and comes from the pens of Helen Saberi, author of Afghan Food and Cookery and Alan Davidson, author of The Oxford Companion to Food and other classics of the kitchen, particularly relating to fish.

Trifles have been a perennial of English summer lunches, tennis parties, and schoolboy dreams. The authors trace their origins to the earliest recipe for trifle of 1596 and its gradual transformation from a mere cooked cream to the many layered custardy extravagance that we know today. The stages on its journey, described with the lightest of touch, are illustrated by recipes extracted from classic English cookery books. The authors thereafter range far and wide in search of the perfect trifle, from Zuppa Inglese to American aphrodisiac trifle to a fruit and tapioca trifle from Laos. As may be imagined from these authors, the material presented is scholarly, yet trips the light fantastic in a way that should appeal the all those curious about the development of our national cuisine.

A puff for Trifle, when Glen Baxter choses his books of the year for The Observer, November 2001

Do Not Bend (Redstone Press £11.95) by David Shrigley is dark, eerie and disturbingly hilarious, like the work of all the very best surrealists. Trifle (Prospect Books £8.99) by Helen Saberi and Alan Davidson, which sparkles with anecdote, generous whippings of erudition and the candied stem of the biznaga cactus. Hugely enjoyable.



Review of Trifle by Jill Dupleix, The Times cook.

There is a trifle, too, of course, but the last word on trifles goes to the learned Alan Davidson and Helen Saberi, their little gem Trifle (Prospect Books £11.99). Having completed their work on the mammoth Oxford Companion to Food Davidson and Saberi turned to the emotional and intellectual comforts of a pudding. Trifle is a knees-up romp through jelly, custard, whipped cream and nuts as the authors dig greedily through layers of culinary archaeology to reveal trifles from "Excellent" to "Aphrodisiac".

In the Companion, Davidson suggests puddings may be claimed as a British invention, and that puddings in all their varieties may be seen as the descendants of botellus, the Latin word for sausage. Two contributing factors to the happy evolution of the pudding in Great Britain, he suggests, were the use of small ovens built into the chimney that allowed the slow baking of a pastry-topped pottage; and the invention of the pudding-cloth, which freed puddings from the need to be encased in animal gut (a haggis and black pudding). Sponge puddings joined suet puddings in the 18th century, and sweet milk pottages embracing new imports such as sago or tapioca joined those made with rice and barley.

The disappearance of the cook from the kitchen means we must now get to grips with basins, bains maries. foil and string to create the puddings to which we are devoted.



Review of Trifle by Elizabeth Riely, editor of the Radcliffe Culinary Times, in Gastronomica.

In this exhaustive examination of the trifle - and with that paradox always in mind - Helen Saberi and Alan Davidson have concocted something as "light and frothy" as their subject. The introduction to this monograph on the British dessert states that during their long years of labor on The Oxford Companion to Food, the authors contemplated just such a project. Here it is, their delight evident, "a smile on every page." Recipes are provided for readers to do further research on their own. Along with their accustomed erudition, Saberi and Davidson write with wit and humor, indeed, with playfulness: "Ah, happy days when we had two trifles a week to sample and discuss over lunch!"

The book begins with a consideration of the trifle's architecture, and the authors apply its structural principles to their writing, from firm foundation to decorative topping. This awareness keeps the book from sinking under its own weight. Trifle is a miniature tour through British culinary history. First stop is its initial appearance in print, in 1596. Further along the itinerary, the authors hail Hannah Glasse who, a century and a half later, invented a dish herself, for once, apparently, rather than plagiarizing her trifle recipe from another cookery writer. She seems to have found the "missing link" between the floating island and the fool, thus publishing the first authentic modern trifle on a base of biscuit, macaroon, and cake, with custard, fruit jelly, syllabub, and flowers above.

The retrospective journey proceeds through British trifles up to the present, including one very much like the one Davidson's Scottish grandmother made. The trifle's flowering outside of Britain, in the New World and beyond, ever further afield, is explored in depth. This "biodiversity" includes variations such as the Norwegian Veiled Maidens with a pumpernickel base, a South African Zulu version with green figs, and an Italian Zuppa Inglese with grenadine and pistachios. Among the sampling of Oddities, most are curiosities rather than temptations. But the Kabul Quince and Yoghurt Trifle, a hybrid of eastern flavors that Saberi created for her Afghan husband, sounds quite delicious. Davidson's Vientiane Coconut Jelly Trifle, with two separate extractions of coconut milk thickened with agar agar, tapioca pudding, and mango, sounds more exotic still.

The Glossary adds nuggets. The boudoir biscuit, for instance, is derived from the French word bouder, to pout; hence "a woman's private room where she would receive only her intimate friends - who could pout and nibble sponge fingers as much as they wished in this cloistered environment." On the final page, a "Valedictory Verse" on the trifle, "where custard and macaroons meet," from Punch, circa 1860, ensures that this book is the last word on trifle.


TABLE OF CONTENTS

Acknowledgements 5
Fast Track Guide 6
Introduction 11
Using the Recipes 13
Trifle Architecture 14

Chapter One - The Early Years 15-18
Thomas Dawson + Jos Cooper + Hannah Woolley + John Evelyn + Robert May + Mrs Mary Eales

Chapter Two - British Trifles 1750 to 1800 19-28
First appearance of Trifle as we know it + Hannah Glasse; Floating Island, Trifle of 1751 + Mrs Powell + Sister Nanny + The Lady's Companion (2 recipes) + Hannah Glasse, A grand trifle + Mrs Cleland + Martha Bradley + Elizabeth Raffald + Sarah Mason + Mrs Maciver + Mrs Frazer

Chapter Three - Trifles in Nineteenth Century Britain 29-38
Mrs Rundell; An excellent trifle, Indian Trifle, Chantilly Cake, or Cake Trifle + Family Receipt Book, A Grand Trifle + Meg Dods, An Elegant Trifle + Eliza Acton, An Excellent Trifle and Very Superior Whipped Syllabubs + A Steeped Cake + Cre-Fyyd, Gooseberry Trifle + Theodore Francis Garrett, Queen of Trifles + Mrs Roundell, Trifle (Family Recipe)

Chapter Four - British Trifles in the First Half of the
Twentieth Century 39-48
Mrs de Salis, Trifle â la Old Century + May Byron; Countess Trifle, Pear Trifle, Lemon Trifle + Violet Farebrother, An Easter Trifle + "Angostura" Trifle + Mrs Leyel and Olga Hartley, the writer's Special Trifle + Apple Snow Trifle + More Favourite Puddings of Rural England, Ratafia Trifle + Irene Veal with a trifle recipe from Reginald Foort + Mrs Kirk, Trifle

Chapter Five - British Trifles from 1950 Onwards 49-64
Views of Elizabeth David + Marguerite Patten; Trifle, Jelly Trifle + Helen Cox, English Trifle + Marian McNeill, Scots Trifle + Comments by Myrtle Allen + Monica Sheridan, Visitors' Trifle + Jane Grigson, Banana Trifle + Summer Syllabub Trifle + Trifle Belle Hél¸ne + Caramelised Orange Trifle + PPC Celebration Trifle

Chapter Six - Trifle in the New Worlds 65-78
Mary Randolph's Trifle (USA) + Mrs Hill's Trifle and Gipsy Squire (USA) + Marion Harland's Peach Trifle (USA) + 200 Years of Charleston Cooking, Trifle (USA) + Ida Lupino as a trifle maker (USA) + Quotation from M.F.K. Fisher (USA) + Ladies of Toronto's Fig Trifle with Almond Custard (Canada) + Lemon Trifle (Australia) + Tango Trifle (Australia) + Trini Tropical Trifle (Trinidad) + Ante de Yemas ('Mexican Trifle') + Viceroy's Dessert (Mexico) + Sopa Inglesa (Argentina)

Chapter Seven - Trifles Elsewhere 79-94
Jules Gouffé's Mousse â L'Anglaise (France) + Plettenpudding (Germany) + Hindb¾rskum med Frugtliker (Raspberry Foam - Denmark) + Tilsl¿rte Bondepiker (Veiled Maidens - Norway) + Ommutriffli (Grandmother's Trifle -ÊIceland) + Any—storta (Mother-in-Law's Torte - Hungary) + Dr Riddell's Trifle (Anglo-Indian) + Snow Eggs forTrifles + Egg-Snow Trifle + The Gulf and the Horn of Africa + Eritrean Trifle + South African Trifles + Hildagonda J. Duckitt's trifle (and pencil)

Chapter Eight - Trifling Relations 95-104
Whim-Wham - Hannah Glasse + Whim-wham - Mrs Dalgairns + Tipsy Cake, or Brandy Trifle (Eliza Acton) + Hedgehog Tipsy Cake (Florence White) + Tipsy Cake Pudding (Lucy Jones) + Tipsy Pudding (Wyvern) + Wassail Bowl (Meg Dods) + Swiss Cream, or Trifle (Eliza Acton) + The Dean's Cream (Florence White) + White Grape and Ginger Syllabub

Chapter Nine - Italy: Zuppa Inglese and Tiramisu 105-110
Zuppa Inglese + A Sicilian Zuppa Inglese + Tirami S¯

Chapter Ten - Oddities 111-117
Cold Savoury Trifle (Theodore Francis Garrett) + Beef Trifle (The 'Pudding Lady') + Kabul Quince and Yoghurt Trifle + Vientiane Coconut Jelly Trifle + London Trifle + Soufflé (Maltese Trifle) + Aphrodisiac Trifle

Glossary of Trifling Terms 118-126
Bibliography 127-131
Measures: Tables of Equivalence 132-133


CHAPTER TEN

ODDITIES 

There can be no doubt about savoury trifles being oddities. So 
we start this chapter with two of them.

We met Theodore Francis Garrett and his monumental Encyclopaedia of Practical Cookery (c. 1895) on page 36, and reproduced his Queen of Trifles, a regal dessert. Here we offer one of his two savoury trifles.

Cold Savoury Trifle

Cut a slice about 1 in thick off a stale loaf, trim it to a square shape, removing all the crust, and make a hollow in the centre. Put a large piece of lard in a frying-pan, and when it boils, put in the bread, and fry it a pale golden brown. Then put it on a sieve to drain. Roughly chop the flesh of a lobster; prepare a nice fresh salad, and place it in a dish. Fill the hollow of the croustade with the lobster, put it in the centre of the salad, and pour over a nicely-flavoured mayonnaise sauce. Ornament the dish prettily with various shapes cut out of whites of hard-boiled eggs, carrots, and beetroot, and serve. If a cold savoury trifle is odd, a hot savoury trifle must be counted odder still. The following recipe for such a surprising item comes from The "Pudding Lady's" Recipe Book by Florence Petty (1917).

Beef Trifle.

1 lb cold meat, chopped finely; 1 tablespoon horseradish, grated; 3 oz breadcrumbs; 1/2 onion, chopped; 2 oz margarine; 1 egg; pepper and salt to taste

Mix well together. Place in small cups, greased. Bake in moderate oven 20 minutes. Turn out and serve on a hot dish with gravy round.

The name of Afghanistan's capital city would not normally conjure up thoughts or visions of trifles, nor would the city of Vientiane in Laos. However, trifles can be conjured up in any part of the world by those who have an inventive spirit and are prepared to apply the English concept of a trifle to ingredients from elsewhere.

Firstly, Helen writes: this recipe has been inspired by my Afghan husband, who asked me to devise a trifle recipe with an eastern flavour, and to name it after the city in which he was born and brought up. The second reason for including this recipe is that the results are really good. An alternative to the yoghurt topping could be an Afghan firni, a sort of custard made with milk and cornflour flavoured with rosewater and cardamon. There is a recipe for this in my book Noshe Djan - Afghan Food and Cookery.

Kabul Quince and Yoghurt Trifle

2 medium quinces
110 g sugar
juice of 1/2 lemon
pinch of ground cardamom
18-24 amaretti biscuits
500 g Greek strained yoghurt
1/4 tsp saffron
1 tbs rose water
110 g caster sugar
1/2 tsp ground cardamom
toasted flaked almonds
slivered or ground pistachio
crystallized rose petals (optional)

Peel, core and slice the quinces thinly. Put into a pan and add water, which should well cover the quinces. Bring to the boil, cover with a lid, turn down the heat and simmer until they are just soft. (You may have to add more water if it reduces too much.) Remove the quinces with a slotted spoon from the pan and set to one side.

Now add the sugar to the water in which the quinces were cooked and stir to dissolve. Add the lemon juice. Bring to the boil and cook for a couple of minutes until syrupy. Remove from the heat, add the cardamom and return the quinces to the pan. Leave to cool in the syrup.

Place the amaretti biscuits in the bottom of a glass bowl and cover with the quinces. Add just enough of the syrup to lightly soak the amaretti.

Now make the yoghurt cream. Dissolve the saffron in the rosewater and beat into the yoghurt. Mix in the sugar, more or less according to taste, and add the cardamom. Mix well.

Spread the yoghurt cream evenly over the quinces and decorated with the almonds and pistachios and rose petals, according to your fancy.
 

Vientiane Coconut Jelly Trifle

Alan's recipe is inspired directly by his experience of living in Laos and exploring the Traditional Dishes of Laos (the title of an extraordinary book on the subject by Phia Sing) including several desserts which have evolved there on the basis of the coconut, most versatile of foodstuffs. It is accompanied by one of only a large number of potential variations. Marry the English trifle to an Asian cuisine and you will be astonished by the number of progeny which this coupling produces.

The ingredients include first and second extractions of coconut milk. To produce these you would need one large or two smaller fresh ripe coconuts and a knowledge of the technique. It is easier for most people to use desiccated coconut, following the instructions on the packet to produce the right amount.

In the recipe which follows, since the versatile coconut can also be used to produce coconut custard, you could substitute this for the tapioca. This would be made with, for example, 4 eggs (lightly beaten), half a cup of sugar and a cup of thick coconut milk. Set over a low heat and stir frequently until you have a custard consistency.

Stage One - The Jelly

2 heaped tsp agar agar (in powdered form)
170 ml thick coconut milk (first extraction)
670 ml thin coconut milk (second extraction)
salt, to taste
70 g brown sugar
70 g white sugar
2 eggs, lightly beaten

Add the agar agar to the thick coconut milk in a cooking pot, stir and bring to the boil. Add salt and both kinds of sugar and leave to simmer for nearly ten minutes. Then add the thin coconut milk to the mixture.

Have your trifle dish, which should be heat-proof, ready. Pour the beaten eggs into the bottom of it.

Bring the coconut mixture back to the boil, then pour it quickly over the beaten eggs and leave to set. (The result, which has settled into a jelly of two layers, the upper one brown and the lower one much paler, can be served by itself as the Lao dessert called Vun, but we are going on to add further layers.)

Stage Two - Fruit and Tapioca

My idea here need not be spelled out in detail, because choice of fruits, quantity of tapioca etc. are all flexible. However, I would suggest making at least two cups of tapioca pudding (I would use 'Minute' tapioca, and follow the directions on the packet) and then setting it aside to cool.

Meanwhile you could thinly slice a banana or two, sprinkle with lime juice, and lay over the vun. Then add a layer of the now cool tapioca, and top with thin pieces of peeled mango, either simple strips or (fancier) crescent shapes, making a decorative pattern. Very thin slices of pineapple would be an alternative topping.

Next we come to something which is not a trifle but by a piece of unparalleled impertinence bears the name. This is followed by something which is a trifle but does not bear the name.

Ann Semple writes: 'Peg Bracken was a woman who made a career in the 1960s of doing as little in and about the house as possible. Her first book, The I Hate To Cook Book, was published in 1960 and was, as I recall, a runaway success. It was quickly followed by several other volumes, all delightful to read and often to emulate: The I Hate to Housekeep Book, (1962); I Try to Behave Myself; The I Hate to Cook Almanack (A Book of Days); and Appendix to The I Hate to Cook Book among others. Of the volumes listed, I now possess every one, including the Appendix in whichI found Peg Bracken's take on trifle.' Her recipe follows:

London Trifle

[Note breath-taking simplicity here]

1 cup yogurt
1 cup marmalade

Mix them up. Then taste. Maybe you'll want more yogurt. Or marmalade. Spoon it into sherbet glasses, grate some orange rind on top, and chill it a bit.

[Note by Alan: In testing this concoction I decided to simplify it further by omitting the sherbet glasses, the grated orange rind and the whole tedious business of chilling. Just leave it all in the bowl (and save on the washing up).]

Anne and Helen Caruana Galizia are co-authors of an admirable book on The Food & Cookery of Malta, which bears many a mark of scholarship as well as practical experience in Maltese kitchens. However, the name of this recipe in their book, which as they point out bears no resemblance to classic French hot or cold soufflˇs, defeated their scholarly enquiries. It seems that no-one has an explanation. But, plainly, we have here a trifle.

Maltese Trifle

Soufflé

375 ml home-made egg custard 
(some of it may be chocolate flavoured)
6 large slices of sponge cake
2-3 tbs apricot or strawberry jam
125 ml brandy, sherry or rum
300 g rikotta
3 tbs caster sugar
50 g dark chocolate, chopped
50 g candied peel

To finish

2 egg whites
50 g caster sugar
bitter chocolate, chopped
almonds, roasted, chopped

Use a large glass bowl. Pour in a layer of custard. Slice the sponge cake and spread with jam. Arrange a layer over the custard. Sprinkle with brandy, sherry or rum. Beat the lumps out of the rikotta and mix with the caster sugar, chocolate and candied peel. Lay a layer of this on the sponge cake. Repeat the process, continuing until all the ingredients have been used up. Finish with a layer of custard.

Whisk the egg whites until stiff. Whisk in the caster sugar. Spoon over the trifle, decorating with more chopped chocolate and some chopped roasted almonds. Clearly the meringue topping must have evolved in the absence of cream.

Since there are still some people in the world who cling to the belief that there are such things as aphrodisiac foods, and since these people might be disappointed if they found that there was nothing relevant to their pet subject in the present book, we conclude it with an item which, sort of, caters to this requirement. We had been intrigued by a recipe for 'White Chocolate Strawberry Trifle' in Inter Courses: an aphrodisiac cookbook by Martha Hopkins and Randall Lockridge (1997) and decided to create our own version. It is a really good trifle. But, no more aphrodisiac quality can be detected in it than in the hundreds and thousands of other foods and dishes which have been hopefully put forward to play the role of the crock of gold at the rainbow's end. The recipe is for 2 people.

Aphrodisiac Trifle

25 g caster sugar / 1 egg yolk
50 g mascarpone cheese
50 ml whipping cream
1/2 tsp vanilla essence
6-8 medium-sized strawberries
50 ml black coffee, flavoured with 1/2 tbs brandy
4 boudoir biscuits
25 g grated white chocolate
crystallised rose petals
Biscuits Roses de Reims (optional)

Beat well the sugar and egg yolk together. Add the mascarpone and beat until smooth. Whisk the whipping cream until stiff, then blend it and the vanilla into the mascarpone mixture and chill.

Slice the strawberries, reserving two whole for decoration.

Break the boudoir biscuits into 4 pieces. Dip the pieces in the coffee and distribute them evenly into two individual sundae glasses. Over each, add in turn layers of chocolate, sliced strawberry and mascarpone mixture. Top each with a whole strawberry and decorate with the rose petals.

Serve with the lovely pink Biscuits Roses de Reims, if desired.


logo
Catalogue by Author
Prospect Books Home Page
Index/Prices/Ordering